Introduction
Why do we have belief systems?
The question, “Why do we need belief systems?” has always been a difficult one to answer. Some people try to answer this question by pointing out that everything we know, we know because we believe it. Then there are other people. For example, take someone who strongly believes in Christianity. This person would say that we need Christianity because Christianity is true. While these are interesting answers to the question, “Why do we need belief systems?” most historians tend to understand belief systems different. Historians often break belief systems into three categories, history, key beliefs and codes of behavior, and state purpose. Historians like to say that everything comes from history, especially belief systems.
For example, Taoism, a Chinese belief system that believes in universal harmony, originated with a historical figure named Lao-Tzu. Lao-Tzu lived in China at the court of the emperor. He was in charge of all the royal records in China. By the time he turned eighty, Lao-Tzu was upset about the way that people in China lived, so he decided to leave for the mountains. As he left, a soldier in the royal palace, impressed by his wisdom, asked him to write all of his knowledge down. He wrote the Tao Te Ching and this is was the birth of Taoism.
Historians also say that we have belief systems to tell people how to behave. The Jewish belief system is based on following a set of rules given to the Jewish people by God. This set of rules is called the Covenant. Most historians say that the Jewish people probably created these rules over thousands of years in the deserts surrounding Mesopotamia. These historians say that the rules of the Jewish covenant are very similar to and probably influenced by Hammurabi’s Code. According to these historians, Judaism evolved as a way to guide the behavior of the Jewish people.
Finally, historians point out that most belief systems have a stated purpose. For example, the state purpose of Buddhism is to rid the world of suffering by riding people of their selfish desire. This purpose came about because the Buddha, who was once a rich Indian prince, saw that people in his kingdom suffered and wanted to try to help them. It is difficult to say for certain why we have belief systems. Some historians think that we have them simply for historical reasons. Other historians think that we have them as a way to control the behavior of people. Still other historians think that belief systems for a specific purpose. Some people disagree and claim we don’t need belief systems at all. Which ever one thinks, it is important to learn about many belief systems so that we can better understand our own beliefs.
Task
Your task is to work through the stages of Design Thinking in order to create an interactive booklet of materials that your peers will use to teach themselves about a particular belief system. Use the following resources to complete the Process phase:
Stanford History Education Group
World History Primary Sources - George Mason University
Library of Congress - Primary and Secondary Sources
Process
DEFINE
Directions: In your group think about your belief system, and below answer the questions. REMEMBER you are trying to teach other students about your belief system! (You may not know all of this information yet but it will guide you when designing your exhibits) Think about what information should be the MOST IMPORTANT when making your exhibits. ANSWER IN FULL SENTENCES!
-
Which belief system do you have?
-
Is your belief system monotheistic or polytheistic?
-
Does your belief system have a specific founder? (ex: Buddha)
-
Is your belief system based on following a set of rules? Is there a sacred text that explains these rules? (ex: Ten Commandments in the Torah or Bible)
-
Is your belief system based on a “state of purpose?” (ex: no materialistic things)
-
Does your belief system observe special holidays? Where do they observe? (ex: Ramadan in Mosques or Christmas in Church)
-
Does your belief system have a history that you are aware of? (ex: confucianism was developed after a cruel dynasty)
-
Does your belief system have important Gods?
-
Is your belief system philosophical, ideological, religious? Are they more than one? What are they?
Does your belief system have a specific place of origin (where it came from)? Did your belief system spread to different parts of the world?
IDEATE
Directions: After looking at your define stage, pick 4 of what you think are the most essential elements to your belief system. These elements are in the form of your questions so should your exhibits be about the founder, set of rules and sacred texts, special holidays and place of worship, state of purpose, place of origin and spread, history, God or Gods, or which type of belief system it is. You can ONLY PICK 4!
PROTOTYPE
Directions PART 1 AND PART 2: You will receive multiple articles for your belief system. All articles contain various information on your belief system. You are only to pick out the 1 piece of information from your ESSENTIAL ELEMENT you choose from your IDEATE STAGE. THEN you will write 2 questions for your exhibit that your peers will have to answer. This question is only based on the information you collected from the article!
PART 1: Information about your essential element: What essential element are you writing this piece of information about (founder, history, set of rules, etc… ) _________________________________________________
Please write the piece of information from your article you will be using for your exhibit below. REMEMBER TO CITE THE SOURCE AND USE THE TITLE!
Article title:______________________________________________________
Article Source (author or where it came from):______________________________________________________
PART 2:Write two questions below that your peers can answer. REMEMBER these questions are based off of the information you wrote above!
-
Question 1 from information above:
Question 2 from information above:
Evaluation
Name:__________________________ Date:_____________ Section:_______Notes#49 Unit: Belief Systems
Name of the Belief system packet you are evaluating: ____________________________________
Belief System - Design Challenge Rubric
|
1 - Beginner |
2 - Apprentice |
3 - Professional |
4 - Master |
|
|
Questioning |
The questions cannot be answered using the information provided.
The questions do not ask the reader to infer. |
The questions can only partially be answered using the information provided.
The questions ask the reader to make an observation |
The questions can mostly be answered using the information provided.
The questions ask the reader to make an inference. |
The questions can be answered completely using the information provided. Directions are provided. The questions ask the reader to make an inference. |
|
Information |
There is no source listed.
The information listed does not relate to the belief system or the essential element. |
The source listed is incomplete.
The information partially relates to the belief system and essential element. |
The information includes a source.
The information includes some important facts about the essential element. |
The information includes a source and title.
The information provides relevant facts and details about the essential element. |
|
Layout |
The image is unrelated to the essential element, or it is inaccurate.
The exhibit is not formatted correctly. Sections are missing. The writing contains spelling and grammar errors. |
The image is somewhat related to the essential element.
Some components of the exhibit are missing or incomplete. |
The image is strongly related to the essential element.
The exhibit is mostly in the correct format, it is complete, and it is mostly free of errors and typos. |
The image is appropriate, accurate, and interesting.
The entire exhibit is organized and formatted correctly (it is free of spelling and grammar errors, and it looks neat and presentable). |
Conclusion
Belief System Grading Guidelines Rubric- Design Challenge Rubric
|
1 - Beginner |
2 - Apprentice |
3 - Professional |
4 - Master |
|
|
Questioning/Answering |
Your peers stated that the questions cannot be answered using the information provided.
Your peers said the questions do not ask the reader to infer.
Your peers were unable to answer questions and you believe it was because you needed to work on your questioning |
The questions were only partially answered using the information provided, your peers only answered part of a question or one question based on back of information from the text |
The questions were mostly answered using the information provided, your peers gave thorough answers detailing the information used in the text and answered the questions according to the details. |
The questions were answered by your peers using the information provided. Your peers were able to make an inference based on the question you gave them. |
|
Grading/discussing a peer's paper |
When discussing your peers work, you were not using the “person first” language. You were speaking about as if they were not in the room, sometimes disrespectfully.
When grading a peer's work you did not look at how they graded your paper. You also did not take into account the issues they may or may not have had when they were answering your questions. |
When discussing a peer's work, sometimes the discussion would not be able their work, sometimes even disrespectfully.
When grading a peer's work you look at some of the feedback they gave you on your feedback form and took some feedback into account but not all. |
When discussing a peer’s paper you discuss their work mostly respectfully and are able to focus on their work most of the time. Mostly using “person first” language
When grading a peer’s paper you are able to take their feedback into consideration, maybe even adjusting how you grade some of their work based on the feedback they receive. |
When discussing a peer’s paper you discuss their work respectfully and are able to focus on their work. Mostly using “person first” language
When grading a peer’s paper you are able to take their feedback into consideration, even adjusting how you grade their work based on the feedback they receive. If most students answer “I don’t know” you are able to be reflective about how you would change your questioning. |
Reflection of design challenge: Look back to the past two weeks of the design challenge and reflect on the work you have done. Answer the question in two paragraphs and really think about the exhibit you made and how your peers did when they were answering your question.
-
How focused do you think you were throughout the design challenge? Were you able to stay on task without having to be redirected?
-
Were you on time with all of you work or was some of your work late? Why?
-
Did your peers understand your exhibit enough to answer the questions you provided? Do you think the questions you gave were challenging enough and why?
-
Were you respectful to your peers work when answering their exhibit questions? How?
-
Were you respectful when you were grading their work? Why do you think you were or were not?
-
What else would you change about your exhibit given the feedback your peers gave you?