Introduction
Do you know the story of Cinderella? You are probably most familiar with the Disney version. But did you know that the story of Cinderella has been told around the world by many different cultures? You are going to listen to and follow along reading to several Cinderella stories from different cultures and are going to be able to identify the differences and similarities to the Disney version. After reading and listening to 6 (six) versions of Cinderella, you will then choose your favorite one, and write an opinion writing stating 5 (five) reasons why it is your favorite. You will be graded using a rubric. Good luck and happy reading!
Task
You will begin by listening to the original Cinderella story as told by Walt Disney. You will then follow the steps to listen to each of the next five versions told from around the world! After each story you hear, you will discuss the story with your partner to find similarities and differences compared to the Disney version. After reviewing all six stories and discussing with your partner, you will write an opinion writing stating which version of Cinderella was your favorite! Convince me why it is the best version by giving 4 reasons. You will be writing on special Cinderella writing paper.
Process
- Hello readers! Click here to listen and follow along to Disney's Cinderella. This is the version we are probably the most familiar with. After listening to the story, discuss the story with your partner. Remember to include: Setting, Characters, Problem, Events, and Solution in your discussion after each story.
- You will now listen to Adelita: A Mexican Cinderella Story by Tomie de Paola by clicking here. This is the Mexican version of Cinderella. Discuss with your partner.
- On to another version! Now you will listen to The Rough-Face Girl by Rafe Martin by clicking here. This version was told by the Algonquin Indians on the shores of Lake Ontario. Discuss with your partner.
- Now you will listen to The Egyptian Cinderella by Shirley Climo by clicking here. This version takes place in Greece. Discuss with your partner.
- Next up is Cendrillon: A Caribbean Cinderella by Robert D. San Souci. Click here to listen! This story takes place in the Caribbean. Discuss with your partner.
- Last, but not least, listen to The Korean Cinderella by Shirley Climo by clicking here. This story takes place in Korea. Discuss with your partner.
Now...think about the six Cinderella stories you heard and read. Which did you like the best? Why? Talk with your partner and give five (5) reasons why you liked that particular story more than the others.
You are ready to write! Write an opinion writing stating what you liked best about the story you chose. Include five (5) reasons in your writing. Give examples. Remember to use capital letters at the beginning of your sentences, and use punctuation at the ends of your sentences.
Evaluation
|
Outstanding 4 |
Proficient 3 |
Approaching 2 |
Beginning 1 |
Score | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
In an opinion writing, write about your favorite version of Cinderella and why you chose it. |
You have included 4 reasons why you chose this particular Cinderella story. |
You have included 3 reasons why you chose this particular Cinderella story. |
You have included 2 reasons why you chose this particular Cinderella story. |
You have included 1 reason why you chose this particular Cinderella story. |
Conclusion
Congratulations! You have successfully traveled around the world with Cinderella! You should now be familiar with six (6) different versions written in different cultures. You should also be able to talk about the differences and similarities of these stories. Perhaps there are more fairy tales you know that have been written in different cultures! Think about some of your favorite fairy tales and research if there are multiple versions just like Cinderella!
Credits
Walt Disney Comapny. Cinderella.
Martin, Rafe. The Rough-Face Girl.
De Paola, Tomie. Adelita: A mexican Cinderella Story.
Climo, Shirley. The Egyptian Cinderella.
San Souci, Robert D. Cendrillon: A Caribbean Cinderella.
Climo, Shirley. The Korean Cinderella.
Teacher Page
EL students can write in their native language, or can draw pictures of the different Cinderellas as an alternative to doing the opinion writing. They can choose to write about the Cinderella closest to their culture as well.